D'Youville won the first game 30-17, before the Bengals rebounded to take game two 32-30. The Spartans claimed the final two games, however, winning 30-22 and 30-27.
Keri Bumgardner (Babylon/W. Babylon) led Buffalo State with 18 kills. Sam Damstetter (W. Seneca/W. Seneca East) added 13 kills and 27 digs.
Buffalo State will close out its home schedule this Thursday against Hilbert at 7 p.m.